Skip to content

Add comprehensive tests for seasonal models and coverage analysis#17

Merged
SZabolotnii merged 2 commits into
develop_sarimafrom
claude/analyze-develop-sarima-readiness-011DRvwF82ZaGu8xt9QKtNhD
Nov 14, 2025
Merged

Add comprehensive tests for seasonal models and coverage analysis#17
SZabolotnii merged 2 commits into
develop_sarimafrom
claude/analyze-develop-sarima-readiness-011DRvwF82ZaGu8xt9QKtNhD

Conversation

@SZabolotnii

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

This commit significantly improves test coverage for the seasonal models introduced in version 0.1.2, addressing a critical gap in the CRAN submission readiness.

New test file: tests/testthat/test-seasonal-models.R (500+ lines) ================================================================ Comprehensive testing for all seasonal model functionality:

SAR (Seasonal AutoRegressive) Models:

  • Basic SAR(0,P)_s model fitting and validation
  • Multiplicative SAR(p,P)_s models
  • Coefficient bounds and convergence testing
  • Multiple seasonal periods (quarterly, monthly)
  • Mean/intercept parameter handling
  • SARPMM2 S4 class structure validation

SMA (Seasonal Moving Average) Models:

  • SMA(Q)_s model fitting with CSS and PMM2 methods
  • Higher-order models (Q > 1)
  • Method comparison and convergence parameters
  • Innovation slot validation
  • SMAPMM2 S4 class structure testing

SARMA (Combined Seasonal ARMA) Models:

  • Full SARMA(p,P,q,Q)_s specification testing
  • Pure seasonal and mixed models
  • Order slot validation and residual properties
  • SARMAPMM2 S4 class validation

SARIMA (Seasonal ARIMA) Models:

  • Differencing order (d, D) handling
  • Non-stationary data processing
  • Full model specification testing
  • SARIMAPMM2 S4 class structure

S4 Methods Testing:

  • coef(), residuals(), fitted(), summary() methods
  • Class inheritance from TS2fit
  • Original series storage and moment statistics

Edge Cases & Integration:

  • Short time series handling
  • Large seasonal periods
  • Constant series edge cases
  • Comparison with stats::arima()

Total: 50+ distinct test cases covering all seasonal functionality

New coverage analysis script: run_coverage_analysis.R ====================================================== Automated script for comprehensive test coverage analysis:

  • Package-wide coverage reporting with covr
  • File-by-file coverage breakdown
  • HTML report generation (coverage_report.html)
  • Identification of low-coverage areas (<80%)
  • Specific focus on seasonal model files
  • Actionable recommendations based on coverage level
  • Data export for CI/CD integration (coverage_data.rds)

New testing documentation: tests/TESTING_GUIDE.md
================================================== Complete guide for developers and contributors:

  • Test structure and organization overview
  • Coverage targets by functionality (>80% overall, >85% seasonal)
  • Running tests (local, devtools, command-line)
  • Coverage analysis instructions
  • Detailed description of test-seasonal-models.R
  • Test data generation utilities
  • Best practices for writing new tests
  • Continuous integration guidance
  • Troubleshooting common testing issues

Updated .Rbuildignore

Added exclusions for development/testing artifacts:

  • run_coverage_analysis.R (dev script)
  • coverage_report.html (generated report)
  • coverage_data.rds (coverage data)
  • tests/TESTING_GUIDE.md (developer docs)

Impact on CRAN Readiness

This commit addresses three critical recommendations from the readiness analysis:

  1. ⚠️ -> ✅ Added comprehensive tests for sar_pmm2(), sma_pmm2(), sarma_pmm2(), sarima_pmm2()

  2. ⚠️ -> ✅ Added tests for S4 classes SARPMM2, SMAPMM2, SARMAPMM2, SARIMAPMM2

  3. ⚠️ -> ✅ Implemented covr-based coverage analysis infrastructure

Expected Coverage Improvement:

  • Before: ~357 lines of tests, estimated 70-75% coverage
  • After: ~850+ lines of tests, target >80% overall, >85% seasonal

These additions significantly strengthen the package's test suite and bring it in line with CRAN quality standards for robust R packages.

Testing on real hardware with R installed is required to verify coverage metrics and ensure all tests pass.

claude and others added 2 commits November 14, 2025 09:53
This commit significantly improves test coverage for the seasonal models
introduced in version 0.1.2, addressing a critical gap in the CRAN
submission readiness.

New test file: tests/testthat/test-seasonal-models.R (500+ lines)
================================================================
Comprehensive testing for all seasonal model functionality:

SAR (Seasonal AutoRegressive) Models:
- Basic SAR(0,P)_s model fitting and validation
- Multiplicative SAR(p,P)_s models
- Coefficient bounds and convergence testing
- Multiple seasonal periods (quarterly, monthly)
- Mean/intercept parameter handling
- SARPMM2 S4 class structure validation

SMA (Seasonal Moving Average) Models:
- SMA(Q)_s model fitting with CSS and PMM2 methods
- Higher-order models (Q > 1)
- Method comparison and convergence parameters
- Innovation slot validation
- SMAPMM2 S4 class structure testing

SARMA (Combined Seasonal ARMA) Models:
- Full SARMA(p,P,q,Q)_s specification testing
- Pure seasonal and mixed models
- Order slot validation and residual properties
- SARMAPMM2 S4 class validation

SARIMA (Seasonal ARIMA) Models:
- Differencing order (d, D) handling
- Non-stationary data processing
- Full model specification testing
- SARIMAPMM2 S4 class structure

S4 Methods Testing:
- coef(), residuals(), fitted(), summary() methods
- Class inheritance from TS2fit
- Original series storage and moment statistics

Edge Cases & Integration:
- Short time series handling
- Large seasonal periods
- Constant series edge cases
- Comparison with stats::arima()

Total: 50+ distinct test cases covering all seasonal functionality

New coverage analysis script: run_coverage_analysis.R
======================================================
Automated script for comprehensive test coverage analysis:
- Package-wide coverage reporting with covr
- File-by-file coverage breakdown
- HTML report generation (coverage_report.html)
- Identification of low-coverage areas (<80%)
- Specific focus on seasonal model files
- Actionable recommendations based on coverage level
- Data export for CI/CD integration (coverage_data.rds)

New testing documentation: tests/TESTING_GUIDE.md
==================================================
Complete guide for developers and contributors:
- Test structure and organization overview
- Coverage targets by functionality (>80% overall, >85% seasonal)
- Running tests (local, devtools, command-line)
- Coverage analysis instructions
- Detailed description of test-seasonal-models.R
- Test data generation utilities
- Best practices for writing new tests
- Continuous integration guidance
- Troubleshooting common testing issues

Updated .Rbuildignore
=====================
Added exclusions for development/testing artifacts:
- run_coverage_analysis.R (dev script)
- coverage_report.html (generated report)
- coverage_data.rds (coverage data)
- tests/TESTING_GUIDE.md (developer docs)

Impact on CRAN Readiness
========================
This commit addresses three critical recommendations from the
readiness analysis:

1. ⚠️ -> ✅ Added comprehensive tests for sar_pmm2(), sma_pmm2(),
   sarma_pmm2(), sarima_pmm2()

2. ⚠️ -> ✅ Added tests for S4 classes SARPMM2, SMAPMM2, SARMAPMM2,
   SARIMAPMM2

3. ⚠️ -> ✅ Implemented covr-based coverage analysis infrastructure

Expected Coverage Improvement:
- Before: ~357 lines of tests, estimated 70-75% coverage
- After: ~850+ lines of tests, target >80% overall, >85% seasonal

These additions significantly strengthen the package's test suite and
bring it in line with CRAN quality standards for robust R packages.

Testing on real hardware with R installed is required to verify
coverage metrics and ensure all tests pass.
@SZabolotnii SZabolotnii merged commit 169feaf into develop_sarima Nov 14, 2025
1 of 6 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants